Saturday, July 20, 2013

Pinterest Tested: Listerine Foot Soak

Welcome to Pinterest Tested! Ever wonder if that miracle cleaner is really miraculous? Or what about that homemade facial cleanser or delicious-looking recipe? This is the place to find out! I am testing Pins that catch my eye to see if they really live up to the claims made on Pinterest. It's like the Mythbusters of Domesticity! 


I am usually pretty anal about foot care because I can't stand crusty alligator feet. But between having a huge pregnant belly (and not being able to reach my toes) and then having a newborn to care for, my feet have been sadly neglected this summer. So when I saw the Pin about a foot soak that was so good, "the dead skin practically falls right off," I knew I needed to test it out.

So I followed the directions. 1/4 cup Listerine, 1/4 cup vinegar, 1/2 cup warm water. Soak for ten minutes.

First problem: that is not enough liquid to cover my feet! So I doubled it and that was just about right.


Ten minutes of soaking, a quick rinse so my feet wouldn't smell like mint pickles, and here are the results:


Meh. It helped. A little. But the dead skin did not "practically fall right off." It just sort of took off the top layer. And the Listerine made my toes tingle/burn. That was a little strange.

I think I'll stick to wearing socks to bed after applying Vaseline and scrubbing with a pumice stone. Unless you have a tried-and-true trick to soft feet. Do share!

26 comments:

  1. I just saw this tip on Pinterest yesterday and was hoping you'd review it. You must have read my mind! Thank you for saving me from the tingly footed awkwardness :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. If you wipe each foot with a Stridex pad before the Vaseline and socks, your feet with thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Something that I do to combat dry feet is to liberally apply Nivea (Vaseline works too) to my feet, cover in saran wrap or ziploc bags, put them in socks and wear for about an hour. Your feet are left silky smooth and last for a while. Last time I did this was 3 weeks ago and my feet are still silky smooth.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for trying this - I've been wondering how it would be

    ReplyDelete
  5. I tried this over summer, I didn't get the results they said I would. I also tried the egg mayonnaise hair and scalp moisturiser and that did work, soft and silky hair. I did this every month over summer and I was happy.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I tried this last week and i agree it wasnt any better than soaking in just water alone.Im still looking for a solution for my poor dry feet.They get too hot to keep socks on at night.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for all the great tips, ladies!

    doodlebugmom... I had to Google what a Stridex pad was. :) That's quite a tip! I'll have to try it!

    And maybe I'll combine that with Bekah's tip of using saran wrap.

    Cambric cotton, pins and needles...did the mayo make your hair smell funny?

    ReplyDelete
  8. My friend's mom tried it with the blue listerine and all it did was dye her feet blue! haha I used pedi peel pads from Avon, they seem to work the best without shredding the skin on my toes.

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Shelby DeSoto That is TOO funny! I'm glad all I had was some tingling tootsies!

    ReplyDelete
  10. I have really calloused and dry feet as well. I use Mary Kay Satin Hands on my feet in the tub. I use the softener first and then apply the scrub part and then scrub with a pumice stone. After I just slather my regular lotion on it and it works wonders. I can get a week out of wearing flip flops before needing to scrub again.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Try the spa sox that are infused
    with Aloe. I think it helps...not a cure but an improvement. Much easier than a lot of the other methods.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I just pinned this same thing the other day and was anxious to try it! So glad I didn't! However, I literally discovered the best, absolute GREATEST, solution this weekend when visiting my brother (who has always had HORRIBLY DISGUSTING feet). We went to Busch Gardens with our families and walked for 12 hours Saturday, and my dry heels just cracked wide open in my tennis shoes and have caused lots of pain. My older brother let me try his solution and it has performed absolute magic on my feet the past couple of days. O'Keeffe's for Healthy Feet! I would describe it as spackle for your feet (seals up the cracks and then leaves them smooth). You can get it at Lowe's, but I ordered mine today on Amazon.com - http://www.amazon.com/OKeeffes-Healthy-Feet-Creme-3-2oz/dp/B0002QB9NE/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1374695718&sr=8-1&keywords=o%27keefes+healthy+feet You will not regret it! He uses the pedicure foot rasp in the shower, then puts the O'Keeffe's on his feet after his shower every day. If you wear sandals in the summer like I do, just do it at night before bed, or in the morning when you have time to let it dry. These other suggestions sound good, too, but definitely pick up some O'Keeffe's next time you're in the home improvement store! It's heavy duty serious stuff! :)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Yeah, I dyed my feet blue using the blue listerine too. I soak my feet in water and hydrogen peroxide. It's cheap and works really well.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I used cool mint Listerine and it turned my feet and toenails green. I scrubbed with soap and it still will not come off. I won't be doing this again.

    ReplyDelete
  15. While its not an immediate results kind of thing I'm not so sure it's completely worthless. I tried this about a month ago and had horrible looking feet. While it didn't seem to do much immediately, I did notice tonight that I don't have the callouses anymore and I haven't had the time to do anything to my feet. So I'm thinking that if used regularly just like alot of other solutions, it will work. Just not a quick fix as it's proposed to be. :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. I did try this about a month or so? ago. The recipe called for soaking your feet for 10 minutes. I used the brown/amber listerine. The dead skin WASN'T falling off after 10 minutes, and I actually soaked for another 10 minutes, and that time there was quite a difference. Still not falling off, but I usually use one of those metal foot graters in the shower once a week anyway.

    HOWEVER, just to really test it, about 2 weeks after doing the listerine/vinegar soak, I used my $10 tiny bottle of foot scrub bought from Sally's, and what I noticed is the listerine actually made my feet SOFTER much longer than my $10 waste ever has!

    I'll keep looking for the miracle cure (and no, it wasn't miracle foot repair either...), but until I find it, I'll keep a foot brush in the shower and keep listerine & vinegar on hand :D

    ReplyDelete
  17. Well this would have been a nice cheap solution, had it worked. I have actually found something that does work though. I bought this stuff called Footner (at Shoppers Drug Mart in Canada, not sure where they carry it in the U.S.) and they are these horrid little plastic booties that don't quite sit on your feet right and you really can't move one they are on. They go on for an hour and then rinse your feet and it looks like absolutely nothing has happened... until you shower the next day. For the next 3 days of foot hell, since you aren't allowed to put any cream on your feet, they will be the equivalent of velcro and stick to everything they touch (so wear socks to bed or you will attach to the sheets) but as you wash your feet, layers and layers of skin scrub off each time, and after 4-6 days.... OMG they looked like normal feet! I have severely cracked skin and the deeper cracks were still there, but apparently you can use this stuff again after 3 months to help solve those.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I just tried the Listerine foot soak and it wasn't any better than soaking my feet in warm water. I still had to use my foot rasp after.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I just tried the Listerine foot soak and it wasn't any better than soaking my feet in warm water. I still had to use my foot rasp after.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Try a coconut scrub!
    1/2 jar coconut oil warmed till liquid
    1 tble spoon lemon juice
    1/2 cup of castor sugar (regular baking sugar) or "to taste" (more sugar just means more abrasive)
    Sit on the edge of the tub with a towel under you. Scrub your feet with the mixture. The longer you scrub the better the results.
    Rinse feet and pat dry. Make sure to wipe out your tub! The oil might make it slippery. Now your feet AND hands are amazingly moisturized!

    ReplyDelete
  21. It worked great for me! I soaked and then used Mr. Pumice from Sally Beauty Supply!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This foot soak worked great for me also! I read reviews beforehand so I knew a little extra help was needed in removing the dead skin. After the 10 minutes I used my foot file (large emery board type file) and lightly rubbed my feet and they were so smooth for many days without any moisturizer! Even my husband was impressed! I used the green listerine and all was well for me, no green feet here.

      Delete
  22. Yes, the amount vinegar, Listerine and water us too little to cover feet. I had doubled the the amount, soaked feet for about 20 minutes. Yes, feet turned blue as, but I used a pumice to rub away dead skin.
    well.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I have the worst heels ever and have tried many home remedies so I thought I would give this one a try as well. Couldn't hurt. I didn't measure, but used approx 1 cup each of white vinegar and no name yellow "listerine". I put in enough hot water to cover my feet. Soaked until water cooled then scrubbed with sponge type pumice. My feet were so soft, callouses and dry skin softened and scrubbed off quite a bit. I slathered on vaseline and put on aloe infused socks. Feet have never been so nice. Looking forward to flip flop season!!!

    ReplyDelete
  24. The trick is to scrub your feet considerably after the soak. I used a foot rasp, stiff brush and manicure stick under warm running water and the dead skin did come off very easily. Much easier than just soaking feet in hot water or after a bath or shower. I was able to remove as much built up dead skin in one sitting than I usually can with 3 times of soaking/scraping and a powered manicure grinder. It seems to be effective at loosening all the thick layers of skin, making it easier to remove but you have to do something to remove it.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Gena makes a fantastic sloughing lotion that I use on my feet when they are bad... I found it through Sally Beauty... at first it doesn't seem like it is doing anything, but if you keep rubbing, the dead skin will start coming off... good luck!

    ReplyDelete

Your kind comments will post after approval.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...